top of page

Beyond Band-Aids: Why Temporary Shelters Aren't the Real Solution To The Housing Problem

Writer's picture: MarioMario

The recent opening of a new homeless shelter in Halifax has sparked a conversation about the effectiveness of temporary shelters in addressing the growing housing crisis. While these shelters promise daily meals, warm showers, and a bed to sleep on, the reality on the ground reveals a different story. The struggle to fill the shelter and the reluctance of encampment residents to relocate shed light on the bandaid nature of temporary solutions. Furthermore, the lack of consultation with constituents raises questions about the efficacy of decisions made by local governments.


a temporary homeless tent shelter

A recent CBC article by Andrew Sampson shed light on the situation unfolding in Halifax. Despite the government's efforts to entice residents with amenities, including warm showers and meals, the shelter remains underutilized. Community Services Minister Trevor Boudreau is quoted as being frustrated at the reluctance of encampment residents to embrace the shelter, emphasizing the available capacity and urging individuals to seize the opportunity. Reason for their reluctance? Many residents say the shelter falls short of providing essential elements of home, such as privacy, autonomy, and community.


As per article, Jeff Karabanow, a professor at Dalhousie University's school of social work, aptly pointed out the multifaceted reasons behind this hesitation... 'negative past experiences, mental health struggles, addiction issues, and a fear of losing their sense of comfort and security all contribute to the reluctance to relocate. The shelter, while offering a roof overhead, fails to address the deeper needs for security, belonging, and care.'


Trullii Modular Home Systems, a vocal protagonist in the housing crisis, advocates for a more proactive and permanent solution. The company believes in building housing faster, better, and with a focus on responsiveness to community needs. Instead of temporary shelters, Trullii proposes permanent affordable apartments. For instance, in the time it took the local government to build the temporary shelter, Trullii Modular could have erected a twelve-story building consisting of 200 two-bedroom apartments.


The juxtaposition is stark: while the government grapples with filling temporary shelters, Trullii Modular could erect a towering building with hundreds of apartments in the same timeframe. This stark reality underscores the urgency for a paradigm shift in addressing the housing crisis. Merely offering temporary respite through shelters is akin to applying a band-aid to a gaping wound—it may stem the immediate bleeding, but it fails to heal the underlying ailment.


Trullii Harmony building. Two hundred apartment building using modular construction.

Access to affordable housing is not a luxury but a fundamental human right. It requires bold, proactive measures that prioritize long-term solutions over short-lived fixes. While temporary shelters may provide temporary relief, they fall short of addressing the systemic issues perpetuating homelessness.


While the government's efforts to provide temporary shelters are commendable, the housing crisis demands a more comprehensive and lasting solution. Trullii Modular Home Systems emphasizes the urgency of building affordable housing faster and more efficiently. It's crucial for local governments to engage with constituents, considering their perspectives and needs, to develop strategies that address the root causes of homelessness. Temporary shelters may offer immediate relief, but they do little to solve the underlying issue. It's time to shift the focus towards sustainable, long-term solutions that ensure every individual has access to a safe and permanent place to call home.

Trullii_white.png

Technology

About

Careers

Tel: +1 782 321.5624

800A Windmill Rd, Dartmouth, NS B3B 1L1

Canada

SUBSCRIBE

Sign up to receive TRULLII news and updates.

Thanks for submitting!

Copyright ©2025. All Rights Reserved. Design: Aliant Brands

  • LinkedIn
  • X
  • Facebook
bottom of page